US Cheddar Output Falls 4.2% As Wisconsin Vats Switch And Butter Churns Take The Milk
US cheddar output fell 4.2% in September while total cheese still grew, USDA figures show. Wisconsin plants moved their milk into other cheese types, and butter churns took more milk as Class IV pricing pulled ahead of cheese milk.

I had filed last month's milk price gap as a story about farm cheques. Then I saw the Wisconsin cheddar line. US cheddar output fell 4.2% in September, to about 140,700 tonnes. Total cheese still grew. My view is that US milk has started to choose its vat, and cheddar is losing.
Cheddar shrinks while the cheese total still grows
The figures come from the USDA's monthly Dairy Products report, released this month. US plants made about 559,300 tonnes of cheese in September. That was 0.7% more than a year earlier. Cheddar went the other way. Its output fell by about 6,200 tonnes on the year. Here is why the total can rise while the biggest type falls. The USDA adds more than a dozen cheese types into one total. Growth in some types can hide a fall in others. September is the month the cheddar fall became too large to hide. In August, cheddar output had barely moved. A sharp drop in a single month is a change of pace. It is the kind of move a cheddar buyer notices in the next contract round.
Wisconsin moves its vats away from cheddar
Wisconsin made most of the national fall. Its cheddar output dropped 16.3% on the year. That is about 3,800 tonnes, close to two thirds of the whole US decline. Yet the state's total cheese output barely slipped. The mechanism is a change of recipe inside the plant. A Wisconsin plant that once made blocks can run the same milk into other types. The state's American cheese fell by about 5,400 tonnes. Its cheese total fell by only about 1,600 tonnes. So most of that milk stayed in the vats and came out as something else. Mozzarella output in the state rose. Wisconsin plants have changed what they sell more than they have lost milk. That matters for anyone buying cheddar from the state. Supply that looked fixed is moving to the cheese that pays better.
Butter churns pull milk away from cheese
The other half of the story sits in the butter churn. US butter output rose 10.9% in September. That added about 9,100 tonnes on the year. It is more than the cheddar vats lost. That happens because of how US milk is priced. A cheese plant pays for its milk on the Class III price. A butter and powder plant pays on the Class IV price. In September, Class IV paid about 2.90 dollars per hundredweight more than Class III. That is about 6 cents more for each kg of milk. When Class IV pays more, milk flows toward the churn and the powder dryer. The reason is simple. A farm or co-op with milk to place sells it where the formula pays most. A cheese plant must then pay a premium to keep that milk. Butter and powder come out of the same plant. Cream goes to the churn and the skim goes to the dryer. A strong powder price lifts the whole plant.
Italian cheese keeps taking the growth
Cheddar's loss is only part of a wider shift in the mix. Mozzarella output rose 4.4% on the year. Parmesan grew faster still, up 14.8%. Italian types are now the largest group of US cheese by a clear margin. In September they came to about 247,600 tonnes. American types, cheddar included, came to about 210,600 tonnes. That gap exists because the two groups sell into different trades. Mozzarella goes onto pizza, much of it under supply contracts with chains. Parmesan is a grating cheese with its own set of food makers and shops. Cheddar blocks sell into a bulk market priced each day in Chicago. A plant on a pizza contract has a buyer before it makes the cheese. A block plant finds its price after the cheese is made. In a soft market, that difference decides where a plant scheduler sends the milk.
The block price tells cheddar plants to make less
The price signal points the same way. In October, the USDA's average block cheese price was 17% lower than a year before. That price feeds the Class III formula, so cheap cheese means cheap cheese milk. Here is why that loop hurts cheddar plants most. A plant making blocks sells at the Chicago price. It also buys its milk on a formula built from that same price. When blocks fall, the milk cost falls with them. The plant's margin stays thin either way. A plant that can switch to a cheese with a contract price escapes that loop. Some plants are leaving block cheese for good. Foremost Farms will close its Marshfield plant in Wisconsin in December. It will stop making 40 lb blocks there. California went the other way, with cheddar up 4.3%. So the fall is a plant by plant choice rather than a national milk shortage. The US still has plenty of milk. It is simply going somewhere else.
The Zenith read: cheddar keeps losing milk into next year
We think US cheddar output keeps falling into early next year while total cheese still grows. The evidence is the price gap. In October, Class IV paid 5.38 dollars per hundredweight more than Class III. That gap is wider than in September, so the pull toward the churn grew stronger. That matters because plants plan their cheese mix weeks ahead. October's milk shows up in the USDA's December report. Over nine months, cheddar output is already down 0.6%. Total cheese is up 2.3% over the same months. We expect that split to widen in the last quarter of the year. Zenith's Global Cheese Database 2026 looks out to the end of the decade. It shows the EU27 and the United States adding over 40% of new cheese volume. So the US question is which types carry that growth. The figure that would change our call is the Class III price. If it climbs back above Class IV, cheddar vats win their milk back.
One month of data rarely shifts a market by itself. What matters is whether the same switch shows up in other dairy countries. Butter and powder pay well in more places than the US this year. Our Global Cheese Database 2026 tracks production, trade and consumption type by type, in tonnes. A move from cheddar to mozzarella shows up there country by country.
Going deeper on this market? See the Global Cheese Database 2026.

Global Water Database 2026
Packaged, bulk, flavoured and premium water in 86 markets, to 2030.
More information
Global Cheese Database 2026
Production, imports, exports and consumption for 39 cheese types across 48 countries, with actuals through 2025 and forecasts to 2030. Buy one market or any five with a single-user, departmental or corporate licence, or get your free database and report sample first.
Get your free database & report sampleStrategic Insights
📊 Analytics & Strategic Insight
US milk is choosing the churn over the cheddar vat
The decision most in this industry are avoiding:
👉 The cheddar shortfall may fix itself through the block price. Fewer blocks means a tighter Chicago market. A firmer block price lifts Class III, and cheddar plants can then bid for milk again.
👉 Cheese plants are choosing simple whey over protein. Wisconsin dried 20.1% more plain whey in September. National whey protein output fell 2.7%.
👉 Small cheese types lose milk first when margins tighten. Feta output fell 19.3% on the year. Swiss fell 7.0%.
Here's the full context:
→ 2025: New US milk pricing rules take effect in June, with higher make allowances for cheese plants.
→ August: Foremost Farms says it will close Marshfield and stop making 40 lb blocks.
→ September: Class IV milk pays more than Class III for the month.
→ October: Class IV leads Class III by 5.38 dollars per hundredweight.
→ Most recent: September cheddar output falls 4.2%. Wisconsin cheddar falls 16.3%.
What this means for cheese producers, traders and buyers:
✅ The cheddar buyer should lock in volume before blocks tighten. US cheddar output over nine months was about 1.35 million tonnes.
✅ The plant scheduler should price each vat against the churn. US butter output over nine months is up 6.5%.
✅ The milk buyer at a cheese plant should budget for a higher premium. US powder output over nine months is up 9.6%, and powder plants want milk.
What this means for market decisions:
1️⃣ US cheese still grows, but the growth sits in Italian types. Zenith expects processed cheese, much of it made from cheddar, to grow under 1% a year to 2030.
2️⃣ Plants with a mozzarella line hold their milk best. They can move milk between types as the price gap changes.
3️⃣ An entrant into US cheese should build for a flexible mix. A single type plant is exposed to one price.
The Zenith view:
This proves the milk price gap is now moving US cheese output. It does not prove buyers will pay more for cheddar. The figure that settles it is October cheddar output, due in the USDA report in early December. A second month down by more than 3% would confirm the switch.
The data behind this story
🧀 Global Cheese Database 2026
Production, imports, exports and consumption for 39 cheese types across 48 countries, in tonnes, with actuals to 2025 and forecasts to 2030. Country workbook plus market insights dossier, delivered by Akos Petri, with a free sample country chapter on the page.
→ See the database
Weighing a US cheese plant or a change in your cheese mix? Zenith helps food and beverage companies assess market size, growth, competitors, pricing and route to market before they invest.
→ Discuss your market
Zenith Consulting
Submit your food & beverage project enquiry.
Share your requirements. If there is a strong fit, we’ll come back with an indicative investment range, project timeline and recommended strategic approach.
Reviewed by Zenith Consulting’s senior food & beverage strategy team.
Our market reports
All reports and databases
Available nowGlobal Aseptic Packaging Market Report 2026
39 markets, 2025 actuals and forecasts to 2030 by category, region and pack type.
View report
Available nowGlobal Cheese Database 2026
48 markets and 39 cheese types: production, trade and consumption to 2030.
View report
Available nowUK Water Drinks Reports 2026
Plain, flavoured and functional water in the UK: companies, brands, own label and forecasts to 2030.
View report
Available nowGlobal Water Database 2026
Packaged, bulk, flavoured and premium water in 86 markets, to 2030.
View report
Available nowGlobal Premium Bottled Water Report 2026
Premium water volume, value and brands, with six country deep dives.
View report
Available nowGlobal Water Dispense Market Reports 2026
Coolers, dispensers and operators across 35+ markets, with forecasts to 2030.
View report- Free tool
Cheese Market Sizer
Size any of 48 cheese markets: 2025 consumption, kg per person, your market share and headroom.
Open free tool
Related analyses
- Corporate Strategy & Portfolio
China Lists All Five Cheese Tariff Codes For US Imports While EU Cheese Pays Up To 11.7%
China has put all five cheese tariff codes on its list of US goods for lower duty, published with the new US-China Board of Trade on 27 September. EU cheese entering the same market pays anti-subsidy duty of up to 11.7%, and New Zealand still holds 61% of the tonnage.
Read analysis → - M&A, Investment & Valuation
Synlait Denies a2 Milk and Fonterra Takeover Talks: Why Buying the Factory Was Never the Fix
Synlait told the New Zealand exchange it is not in talks with a2 Milk or Fonterra, the same day a2 Milk reported China-label infant formula sales down 14% on supply problems at that plant. The deal the market wanted would not have fixed the problem, because the scarce asset in infant formula is a China registration and there are only three per factory.
Read analysis → - Corporate Strategy & Portfolio
Tetra Pak Completes 30.2 Million Euro La Rioja Upgrade As Argentina's Only Aseptic Carton Plant Looks To Chile
Tetra Pak has finished a 30.2 million euro upgrade at La Rioja, the only aseptic carton converting plant in Argentina, with capacity for 3.5 billion packs a year. About 40% of its output is exported, mostly to Chile, where aseptic demand is growing faster than in Argentina.
Read analysis →
Share it with your peers
Pass this analysis to colleagues who track the food and beverage market.
Zenith Market Intel
Need a specific food or beverage market report?
Tell us which category, region or question would be useful for your team.
Sister Publication
Also follow our Water Dispense Market Intelligence
Category analyses, operator briefings, and investor signals across the global water dispense market.