Saputo's US Profit Rises 22.8% On Whey Protein While The US Milk Formula Caps The Cheese Margin
Saputo's US profit rose 22.8% in its second quarter while its cheese faced an unfavourable milk-cheese spread. The US Class III formula caps the cheese maker's margin, so the gain came from whey protein the formula prices as plain dry whey.

One figure in this result changed how I read it. Saputo sold a little less in America this quarter and earned far more. Its US profit rose 22.8% in the three months to September, while its cheese had a hard quarter. I think that split tells you how the US market really works. In America the cheese price pays the farmer. The whey pays the plant.
Profit rose while sales fell
Saputo reported its second quarter on 5 November. US profit on its adjusted measure reached 205 million Canadian dollars. A year earlier it was 167 million. US sales slipped 0.6% over the same period. So the margin widened to 9.6% of sales. That matters because the gain did not come from cheese. Saputo says lower average block and butter prices pulled US sales down. It names higher prices for its high protein ingredients as the main lift to profit. On cheese it was blunt. It said cheese market dynamics stayed hard because of an unfavourable milk-cheese spread. US volumes still rose, in high protein ingredients and in cheese, mozzarella included. So the plants ran fuller. The cheese earned less on each pound, and the whey earned more.
How America prices milk for a cheese plant
To see why, look at how the US prices milk. The benchmark for cheese milk is the federal Class III price. It is built from three market prices: cheese, butter and dry whey. Here is why that matters. The cheese price sets most of the milk value. USDA takes the average block cheddar price each month. It subtracts a fixed make allowance. It then multiplies by a standard cheese yield. Since June 2025 the cheese make allowance has been about 25 cents a pound (56 cents a kg). In September the block price averaged 1.56 dollars a pound (3.43 dollars a kg). So the formula hands the plant a set sum for each pound of cheese it could make. That sum has to cover labour, energy, packing and profit. Everything above it goes to the farmer through the milk price.
Why the cheese margin cannot run away
This is the mirror image of New Zealand. There, the milk price leaves cheese out, so a cheese rally lands with the plant. In America the cheese price is written into the milk price. So when blocks rise, the milk bill rises with them, and the cheese maker keeps roughly the same margin. When blocks fall, milk gets cheaper at about the same pace. The plant is left holding the make allowance either way. That happens because the formula treats cheese making as a fixed cost service. Real costs do not stay fixed. Saputo cites higher labour, logistics and packing costs this quarter. Those come straight out of a margin the formula has capped. Timing adds a second squeeze. Milk is priced on a monthly average, while cheese is sold on its own cycle. A falling market can leave stock made from dear milk and sold at cheap block prices. Saputo also expects more US cheese, as milk output rises and herds grow. More cheese pushes blocks down. The formula then passes most of that fall back to the farmer.
Where the formula stops counting
The formula has one blind spot, and it sits in the whey. The whey solids in milk are priced as if they all become dry whey. Dry whey is the plainest product a cheese plant can make. In September dry whey averaged 67 cents a pound (1.48 dollars a kg). That price set the whey part of the milk bill. A plant that filters the same whey into WPC80 sells a very different product. WPC80 is whey protein concentrate, roughly four fifths protein. Sports, health and high protein foods want all of it they can get. In October USDA Dairy Market News had WPC80 trading from the mid 9 dollars to 10 dollars a pound. That is over 20 dollars a kg. The reason this matters is simple. The milk bill does not rise when WPC80 rises. The plant buys the whey at the dry whey price and sells it as protein. Every cent of that gap stays with the plant.
The same pattern runs across the group
The same pattern shows up outside America. Canada held flat at 179 million Canadian dollars, even after higher selling prices. Canadian milk is priced under supply management. When milk costs rise, the plant has to raise its own prices just to keep level. Australia was the fast mover. Its profit rose 38.5% on the year. It reached 54 million Canadian dollars. Saputo again credits higher protein prices, plus more milk after better weather. That happens because a plant with spare drying capacity can turn extra milk into protein quickly. Cheese takes longer. It has to ripen, and it sells into slower retail contracts. Mozzarella is the cheese Saputo is pushing hardest. It says its sales plan backed mozzarella growth with major customers and in export markets. That fits the wider market. Zenith's Global Cheese Database 2026 puts fresh cheese, mozzarella included, at over a third of consumption. It is also the fastest growing family, at about 2.4% a year to 2030.
The Zenith read: the whey plant decides US cheese returns
We think US cheese margins stay pinned near the make allowance through 2027, while protein carries the profit. The reason is the formula itself. It caps the cheese margin by design and leaves the whey upside open. Saputo plans to spend about 500 million Canadian dollars this year, more than last year. Its outlook expects its US ingredients to keep their momentum. That is where we expect much of the money to go. So the US cheese plant worth owning is the one with a whey protein plant beside the vats. A plant that still dries plain whey sells its best stream at the formula price. The figure that would change our call is the WPC80 price. If new US whey plants pull it below about 15 dollars a kg, the protein lift fades. Then the cheese margin matters again, and it stays thin. That settles the claim this piece opened with. In America the cheese price pays the farmer. For now, the whey pays the plant.
We will be watching how many US cheese plants add protein drying as the new herds come on. The cheese side of that balance is what our Global Cheese Database 2026 measures. It tracks US production, trade and consumption in tonnes, with forecasts to 2030. The same series runs for 39 cheese types across 48 markets.
Going deeper on this market? See the Global Cheese Database 2026.

Global Water Database 2026
Packaged, bulk, flavoured and premium water in 86 markets, to 2030.
More information
Global Cheese Database 2026
Production, imports, exports and consumption for 39 cheese types across 48 countries, with actuals through 2025 and forecasts to 2030. Buy one market or any five with a single-user, departmental or corporate licence, or get your free database and report sample first.
Get your free database & report sampleStrategic Insights
📊 Analytics & Strategic Insight
America caps the cheese margin by rule and leaves the whey protein open
The decision most in this industry are avoiding:
👉 A plant that still dries plain whey is giving away its best stream. The formula valued September whey solids at 41.47 cents a pound (91 cents a kg). Protein buyers pay many times that for the same solids once filtered.
👉 A US cheese rally is mostly good news for farmers. The September protein price in milk was 2.66 dollars a pound, built almost wholly from the block price. When blocks climb, that number climbs, and so does the milk bill.
👉 More US cheese also means more whey chasing the same protein buyers. Saputo expects herd growth to lift cheese supply. Every new vat adds whey, so the protein price is the next thing to watch.
Here's the full context:
→ June 2025: USDA's new milk formulas took effect. The cheese make allowance rose to 25.19 cents a pound.
→ August 2026: Saputo agreed to sell its UK dairy arm to Lactalis. Expected proceeds are about 1.66 billion Canadian dollars.
→ September 2026: Saputo gave dairy ingredients its own division. It was a clear bet on whey protein.
→ October 2026: September Class III milk was priced at 16.04 dollars a hundredweight. That is about 35 dollars for 100 kg.
→ Most recent: Saputo reported US profit up 22.8% on 5 November. It blamed its cheese results on an unfavourable milk-cheese spread.
What this means for cheese producers, traders and buyers:
✅ The plant controller should report cheese margin and whey margin as two lines. One blended margin hides which stream earned the quarter. In the US the answer is now usually whey.
✅ The milk buyer should expect protein plants to outbid plain cheese plants for milk. A plant that earns more on whey can pay more over the formula. Plain plants lose milk at the edge first.
✅ The ingredients sales desk should lock longer protein contracts while supply is tight. New whey capacity is coming as US herds grow. Today's protein price will not hold forever.
What this means for market decisions:
1️⃣ US cheese pays best with a protein plant attached. The formula caps the vat. The upside sits in the whey stream, and that is where returns are made.
2️⃣ Groups with protein drying gain ground, while plain dry whey plants fall behind. Saputo's Australian margin reached 7.7%, lifted by protein prices. Plain whey plants have no such lever.
3️⃣ An entrant should price the whey plant before the cheese room. Zenith forecasts more than 40% of new cheese tonnes to 2030 in the EU27 and the US. That means a lot of new whey in two places.
The Zenith view:
This proves whey protein can carry a US cheese business through a weak cheese market. It does not prove the protein price will hold as new plants start. The figure that settles it is the US whey protein price in the first half of 2027. Saputo's third quarter in February gives the first read.
The data behind this story
🧀 Global Cheese Database 2026
Production, imports, exports and consumption for 39 cheese types across 48 countries, in tonnes, with actuals to 2025 and forecasts to 2030. Country workbook plus market insights dossier, delivered by Akos Petri, with a free sample country chapter on the page.
→ See the database
Weighing a US cheese plant or a whey protein investment? Zenith helps food and beverage companies assess market size, growth, competitors, pricing and route to market before they invest.
→ Discuss your market
Zenith Consulting
Submit your food & beverage project enquiry.
Share your requirements. If there is a strong fit, we’ll come back with an indicative investment range, project timeline and recommended strategic approach.
Reviewed by Zenith Consulting’s senior food & beverage strategy team.
Our market reports
All reports and databases
Available nowGlobal Aseptic Packaging Market Report 2026
39 markets, 2025 actuals and forecasts to 2030 by category, region and pack type.
View report
Available nowGlobal Cheese Database 2026
48 markets and 39 cheese types: production, trade and consumption to 2030.
View report
Available nowUK Water Drinks Reports 2026
Plain, flavoured and functional water in the UK: companies, brands, own label and forecasts to 2030.
View report
Available nowGlobal Water Database 2026
Packaged, bulk, flavoured and premium water in 86 markets, to 2030.
View report
Available nowGlobal Premium Bottled Water Report 2026
Premium water volume, value and brands, with six country deep dives.
View report
Available nowGlobal Water Dispense Market Reports 2026
Coolers, dispensers and operators across 35+ markets, with forecasts to 2030.
View report- Free tool
Cheese Market Sizer
Size any of 48 cheese markets: 2025 consumption, kg per person, your market share and headroom.
Open free tool
Related analyses
- M&A, Investment & Valuation
Danone Just Took a Whole Country Off Its Revenue Line. The Arcor Deal Shows Why Deconsolidation Is Now a Strategy
Danone and Grupo Arcor completed their 50/50 Argentine dairy joint venture on 1 August, moving Danone's entire Argentine dairy business off the reported revenue line and into a single equity-accounted line. Reported sales will fall, the guided growth number will not move, and that is exactly the point.
Read analysis → - Sustainability, Regulation & Risk
Namibia Dairies Installs 8,000 Packs An Hour Tetra Pak Aseptic Line To Defend Local UHT Milk From South Africa
Namibia Dairies has installed a Tetra Pak line that fills up to 8,000 packs of long life milk an hour and adds a 500 ml pack. It is a defence of the home shelf against South Africa, the carton giant next door.
Read analysis → - Corporate Strategy & Portfolio
SIG Neo XSlim 32 Aseptic Fills 32,000 Single-Serve Cartons An Hour: A Third More Output In The Same Floor Space
SIG has added two aseptic carton filling machines to its Neo range, one at 32,000 single-serve cartons an hour and one at 15,000 multi-serve. Both claim a third more output per square metre in the same footprint, which puts floor space ahead of demand as the limit on new carton capacity.
Read analysis →
Share it with your peers
Pass this analysis to colleagues who track the food and beverage market.
Zenith Market Intel
Need a specific food or beverage market report?
Tell us which category, region or question would be useful for your team.
Sister Publication
Also follow our Water Dispense Market Intelligence
Category analyses, operator briefings, and investor signals across the global water dispense market.